Tregolwyn Book Reviews

Saving the King

Science fiction and fantasy reading
Photo Album
Featured Publishers
How to use this site
Index of Authors and Titles
Reviews: Fiction
Reviews: Non-Fiction
Reviews: Poetry
Our Reviewers
Contact Us
Read an extract
Interview with CORNELIA GOLNA
SPECIAL FEATURE: Clare Potter comments...
Success Stories

by Robert P Oldham


ISBN 0 9689382 5 6
Published by Standmar, 2002
   pp, paperback
Retail price $

Open Book

Review by Chris Williams

Sometimes you come across a great image in a book, one that you know will stay with you. It is 1940 and the Germans have invaded Britain and won. In the back of a captured German staff car, Queen Elizabeth (who we later came to know as the Queen Mother) is firing a revolver back at pursuing Germans. She is resplendent with a pink eye-patch over her right eye, an eye she lost in a raid on Buckingham Palace, a raid in which her husband, the King, died.

Now, if a book can come up with an image like that, don't you want to read it?

This is, as can be seen from the above, an alternative history of the Second World War. This is, of course, not a new idea, but what I like about this one is the sheer exuberance with which it is written. Mr Oldham obviously obtained a great deal of pleasure out of it. He is a Canadian, so naturally enough the heroes of his book are, in the main, Canadian, but why not? At least they're not Americans, for which we should be grateful.

The book is somewhat episodic and Oldham jumps from action to action almost as if he wrote a much longer book and has edited out chunks of it to present us with what we have in hand. Thus we start with John Stafford, a 17-year-old Canadian "doing" Europe, getting employed to spy on the Nazis and, in the process, preventing an assassination of the Crown Prince of Romania. He also stops some Italian submarine saboteurs. Later, when war breaks out, he enrols and later becomes a Commando. He rescues the Duke and Duchess of Windsor, about to be crowned King and Queen by the Nazis, from the Tower of London, together with the last Yeoman and 4 Ravens.

Does this all sound something like a Boy's Own adventure? That is not at all surprising, for that is just how it struck me, and it was no worse for that. This book is, from beginning to end, just plain good fun and I, for one, found that peculiarly refreshing.

There are some nice ideas in this book as well though. My favourite was Pearl Harbour doesn't happen and America enters the war, not when Germany invades Britain, but when they invade the Republic of Ireland, which is being used as a source of arms for the British Resistance under Queen Elizabeth and led by Oliver Wingate. How perfectly logical is that?

If I have a complaint with the book, it's with the last 40 pages. These consist of an extensive list of characters and a glossary of terms. These were obviously created or researched by Oldham in his probably extensive development of this book. This is fine and I actually found them quite interesting. My problem is that some of the characters, in particular, seem almost better developed in the list than they were in the body of the work. I think the author could have better used these 40 pages in adding to and filling in gaps in his actual story. 

That said, I will still say that this was a fun, entertaining read and, if it left me with nothing else, at least now whenever I see film of Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother, smiling and waving, I can see her with a pink eye-patch, shooting, accurately of course, at her and our enemies. Bravo!

Buy this book from Amazon

If you like this, you'll probably like:

New Britain KZ1