Tregolwyn Book Reviews

Women Are Our Only Hope

Science fiction and fantasy reading
Photo Album
Featured Publishers
How to use this site
Index of Authors and Titles
Reviews: Fiction
Reviews: Non-Fiction
Reviews: Poetry
Our Reviewers
Contact Us
Read an extract
Interview with CORNELIA GOLNA
SPECIAL FEATURE: Clare Potter comments...
Success Stories

by Anthony DiGiorgio


ISBN 1 4208 8468 9
AuthorHouse, 2006
40pp, paperback
Retail price $9.40

Open Book

Review by Deborah Fisher

The first surprise about this book is that it was not written by a woman. The second is that, contrary to the expectations raised by the title, Anthony DiGiorgio does not seem to have a high opinion of the female gender. He just doesn’t think much of men. Although he begins with a list of reasons why Women Are Our Only Hope, it quickly turns into a set of instructions directed mainly at women, advising us how we might go about changing the situation. Presumably Mr DiGiorgio doesn’t think we have any ideas of our own on that subject.

If I sound cynical, it is the didactic tone of the book I find off-putting. If a writer wants to persuade others of the correctness of his view, this is not the way to do it. "It is up to you to teach your children the stupidity of religion…" he hectors, showing little respect for other people’s point of view. "Start by getting together with other women and admit that you have had enough." It would be nice to think that these are the words of a second Frederick Pethick-Lawrence, but I somehow feel that Mr Pethick-Lawrence would not have lasted long in the women’s suffrage movement if he had ordered Mrs Pethick-Lawrence around like this. The logic, too, is wobbly. The premise of the pacifist message that comes through so strongly is that it is women alone who give birth to the babies that make the soldiers who are sacrificed in war. And there was me thinking that all children had fathers!

What Women Are Our Only Hope is in fact about has little to do with gender equality. It is actually an anti-war book, and it is entirely Americo-centric. All the author’s suggestions are geared towards improving the government and society of the United States and have little relevance for residents of any other country in the world. Apparently there are 2000 generals and admirals in the USA, which does, I agree, seem a lot, but then the USA has a population five times that of the UK. More to the point, it is difficult for the rest of us to see how changing the USA will resolve the problems of the world overnight.

I wish I could say that the argument is well-presented. Unfortunately, although the spelling and punctuation are correct, Mr DiGiorgio’s writing is hardly a paragon of English prose. "Make them compete for the knowledge that will help them, versus for [sic] the glamour of victory," he says, advising us – or rather the Americans – to end the teaching of sport in high schools. It is very odd to see this amalgam of liberalism and radical pacifist views mixed in with a deep-rooted conservatism that comes out with statements like "rapists…should be sexually neutered" and "civil servants are parasites who feed on the sweat of nongovernmental affiliated workers" (whatever that last phrase means).

In summary, this book is no more than a rant. I have no doubt that Anthony DiGiorgio means well, that he genuinely wants to change the world, and that he has thought long and hard about how this might be achieved. I may even agree with some of his statements. Yes, women do tend to accept inequality as the norm, and yes, they do need to be shocked into doing something for themselves. But do they need this author to tell them how they should behave? I don’t think so.