Tregolwyn Book Reviews

Imogene of the Pacific Kingdom



Home
Science fiction and fantasy reading
Photo Album
Featured Publishers
How to use this site
Index of Authors and Titles
Reviews: Fiction
Reviews: Non-Fiction
Reviews: Poetry
Our Reviewers
Forthcoming
Contact Us
Read an extract
Archive
Interview with CORNELIA GOLNA
SPECIAL FEATURE: Clare Potter comments...
Success Stories

by Teresa Saari

imogene.jpg

ISBN 1 4120 1642 8

Trafford Publishing, 2004

234pp, paperback

Retail price US$19.25, C$24.99, EUR16.24, 11.26

 

 

 

Buy this book from Amazon

The influence of J K Rowling on Theresa Saari is not immediately evident to the untrained eye, but it is there. Imogene of the Pacific Kingdom takes the basic ingredients of a Harry Potter novel and stirs them around a bit, with the heroine being abandoned by her parents and made to live with an unsympathetic relative until she comes of age, is able to make use of her unusual powers, and is taken by a mysterious mentor to her rightful home. This is just about where the resemblance ends. Besides, the themes of separation from parents and a special destiny are traditional ones in children’s literature: Peter Pan, the Famous Five, the Pevensey children in C S Lewis’s Narnia books, all of them start off in this way.

Ms Saari describes Imogene of the Pacific Kingdom as being dedicated to children of all ages, from six to 106, but it is unquestionably a story primarily intended for the former rather than the latter. It succeeds on several levels – but fails on others. The flaws are mostly stylistic. Young readers are unlikely to notice the errors in grammar and punctuation, and the misuse of "lay" as an intransitive verb is by now habitual in the UK as well as in North America, so there is no point griping about it. There are, however, three things noticeably lacking in the author’s style of writing.

The first is economy. Detail is a fine thing, but many sentences appear padded out with excess verbiage, and it often takes a whole paragraph to convey what could have been said in a single line.

"Finally they walked enough and rounded many bends, and the Royal Family and their friend made it to the lake."

This is a common failing among new writers, and one that can be easily conquered. The other two missing elements are humour and metaphor; these are more serious weaknesses, especially in a children’s author, and will need to have attention given to them if this is to be the first in a successful series.

On the whole, the book is short on comic moments. The raw material is there, particularly in the character of Sampson, the butler, who in his present form is little more than a good-humoured Lurch but has the potential to develop. The lack of colour in Ms Saari’s style is puzzling, as this is one of the areas where budding writers tend to go over the top. Such similes as occur here are rather uninspiring:

"The coffee table … was the size of a small dining room table…"

"it was a silk robe; shiny as can be…"

When Imogene’s parents eventually call for her, there is plenty of scope for the imagination. The questions about her new lifestyle come thick and fast, and are answered with considerable ingenuity. A lot of effort and skill has gone into creating this magical alternative world where young readers can immerse themselves. Needless to say, Imogene’s problems are not over, for here comes a villain to threaten her idyllic future, and she has to go back to square one before she can return to fulfil her destiny. This is the material of which best-sellers are made.

One thing I particularly like about the book is the quirky cover, which somehow adds to the story’s air of mystery. It would have been easy to produce an image of blue sea, blue sky, and a fairytale princess. Far better to let the reader’s own imagination do the work.

Open Book

Review by Deborah Fisher